Simple Soft Shell Crabs at Home

I am gratefully back in the kitchen again creating more simple seasonal meals. Today I am sharing my super simple version of soft shell crabs.

But first, I have a true confession. I was afraid to invest in soft shell crabs because I had this story in my head that they must be hard to make. I didn’t want to waste my time and money on a failure.  On a recent shopping trip, my husband (an enjoyable outing for us, now that the kids are grown) spotted fresh soft shell crabs and suggested we bring some home.

Yikes! I thought, they must be hard to make, because I have only seen them in nice restaurants. However, I am a little overconfident and maybe even cocky in the kitchen, probably due to my Italian heritage.  

Sooooo I agreed to bring them home. I covertly whispered to the fishmonger to tell me the secret to cooking them. To my surprise, he said all they need is a flour dredge and to be sautéed in a pan. Ok, I thought, this can’t be any harder than making chicken french, which is oddly popular in Italian restaurants around here.


Simple Soft Shell Crabs


  • 8 fresh soft shell crabs
  • 1 cup of fine flour for dredging, preferably with salt and pepper, ( If not, generously add fresh ground salt and pepper)
  • 2 eggs
  • Olive oil
  • 1-2  Tbsp. Truffle butter or grass-fed butter


  • 3 paper lunch bags (the old-fashioned brown variety)
  • Shallow bowl for an egg bath
  • Tongs
  • Heavy bottomed large skillet (I prefer cast iron)
  • food thermometer


  1. Set up:
  • Heat a skillet over medium heat, and add a swirl of oil enough to coat the bottom. Add the butter.  
  • Cut two of the bags open so that they lay flat, and set aside. Fill the last bag with the flour (and salt and pepper)
  • Mix the eggs in the shallow bowl
  • Set up an assembly line near the stove: flour bag, eggs, flat bags for draining the cooked crabs.
  1. Prepare and cook:
  • Using tongs, drop a crab in the flour bag, shake it lightly,  then dip it the egg bath, and return it to the bag for another flour shake.
  • Add the crab to the pan on medium heat.
  • Repeat until the pan is full
  • Use a thermometer to check for doneness. Crabs are done at 130 degrees, according to my fish guy. Ps- They cook fast.
  • Remove crab with tongs and lay on paper bags to drain
  • Repeat for remaining crabs, adding in more oil & butter if needed.


That’s it!

We enjoyed them on top of our Lazy Caesar Salad with a side of corn on the cob for a simple summer supper.  

No more waiting to go out for soft shell crab. This was so easy, and throwing out the paper bags made for an easy cleanup!

FREE Video Series: The Best Exercises for Women Over 40!


Free 3-Part video Series goes in-depth teaching you how to perform the above exercises step-by-step THE RIGHT WAY without getting hurt.

Watch the Videos

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

seventy eight + = eighty